[BIRD33]

mcnabb is one of the best qb's of his era
they all have flaws

are you gonna tell me now that he is gone that he was no good??

I agree with Baldinger that he is one of the most overrated QB's ever.He can win games during the regular season.Playoffs he's a choke artist.Puked in the super bowl, lost NFC title games while favored, lost to the Cardinals two years ago in the NFC title game despite being down a few points with the ball on the cards 45 with less then 2 minutes to go.Thats the only body of work that matters.Guys servicable no doubt but not a winner.I'd compare him to Patrick Ewing but thats an insult to Ewing since he had heart.This isnt Buffalo where we are just happy to be in the league.Add in the fact the guy has a history of being disingenuous and pointing fingers as well as crying about criticism in a hard nosed town that doesnt take well to whiners whose parents speak for them(Lindros) and its easy to see why he's not really missed.